Top 5 Eyeliners.

As a beauty blogger, I own too many beauty products to properly review them individually. Oftentimes I surprise myself by how little I talk about the products that I use regularly. In 2015, I’m going to try to streamline and combine product reviews in order to give each product the love and mention they deserve as well as feature more products in the rotation!


Eyeliner is something I wear on a daily basis, but have rarely reviewed or mentioned on the blog. There are a few particular favourites of mine that I never properly gave a shoutout to. Hopefully by featuring more varieties and products, I have given you some inspiration your upcoming shopping trip!

When it comes to eyeliners, I think my standard for a good eyeliner is quite universal – it should never smudge. I’m not asking for a lot am I? I mean, who wants the panda look at the end of the day? That it lasts all day or easy to manoeuvre are more of a bonus to me. In this post, I’m going to go through my top 5 eyeliners that have passed the test.



Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner | $26 | available here
This eyeliner became something I reached for every single day as soon as I started using it. I loved it so much that it was the only eyeliner I brought with me on my recent vacation. The Stila eyeliner features a very fine tip applicator and an excellent formula. I have not come across a black eyeliner formula that is as good as Stila’s. It lasts through hours of kickboxing, and pouring rain, so you can definitely bet this eyeliner will look fresh, even after the end of an 8 hour work day. There’s no trace of smudge or flakes in the months that I’ve been using the Stila eyeliner, so that is one less thing you have to worry about. Despite the name, the eyeliner is very easy to remove at the end of the day – a little bit of the L’Oreal Micellar Water or the Bioderma Micellar Solution will work its magic.

Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil | $24 | available here | review
The Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil is quite legendary in the beauty world – when I wanted to purchase my very first high-end eyeliner from Sephora, this was the product that constantly showed up in my research. The formula makes application super easy with these pencils – the eyeliner glides smoothly with a very even colour pigmentation. No tugging on your sensitive eye area, guaranteed! The formula lasts a very long time as you would expect from the name, however I find that setting my undereye with powder is absolutely necessity otherwise a bit of smudging is inevitable.

Make Up For Ever Artist Liner | $23 | available here | review
Make Up For Ever Artist Liner formulation makes it quite hard some times for other products to get back into your regular rotation. The creamy formula, as well as superb pigmentation that doesn’t transfer nor smudge, makes it a step up to the Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil. Despite the pencil format, and the creamy texture, I was surprised to find no sign of smudging or flakiness at the end of the day with this range. One thing you should be aware of is that the pencil doesn’t twist back down. So don’t overtwist otherwise you’ll be left crying after a broken $5 chunk on the floor.

Inglot AMC Gel Eyeliner in 77 | $12
For a budget version of an eyeliner that will last you a very, very long time, Inglot is my go-to brand. This creamy gel formula is comparable to the legendary MAC and Bobbi Brown gel liners, at a fraction of the price. The colour is truly one of the blackest black shade I’ve come across and the texture is very rich, and creamy – almost like melted chocolate. It dries quickly, leaving little room for making mistakes, but once it’s on, it doesn’t smudge. I tend to find it work best on the top lashes and avoid using this formula on the waterline as it tends to run and smudge.

Make Up For Ever Ink Liner | $27 | available here
The new eyeliner innovation from Make Up For Ever comes in this calligraphy-pen eyeliner format. The fine felt tip picks up just the right amount of product and is easy to manoeuvre in your hands to achieve that perfect eyeliner look. The formula is a rich, pigmented black that stays put irrespective of what the nature throws at you. The formula dries quickly, though not as quickly as Inglot’s so you will have time to fix any mistakes. When I was learning how to created that cat-eye, winged look, I found this calligraphy-pen format to be the easiest to use and control as it gave me cleaner lines, and more precise strokes. Although priced slightly at a premium compared to the Artist Liner, ultimately the choice comes down to preference.


Inglot AMC Gel Eyeliner in 77 // Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil // Make Up For Ever Artist Liner // Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner // Make Up For Ever Ink Liner

Now it’s your turn! Have you tried any of these eyeliners before? What are your favourite eyeliners and format? As always, I’d love to hear your thoughts! Share with me comment section or through Twitter or Instagram!

Disclaimer: This post features product(s) provided for editorial consideration. All opinions are my own. For more information about my review policy, please click here.

Great picks! I’m a big fan of MUFE and UD eye pencils myself ????

They are quite good aren’t they?

i’m really liking the MUFE Ink Liner. and i love the UD pencils! i have bought the one in Demolition over and over again.

A Beautiful Zen

Ooh, super nice picks! I’m a huge fan of the UD 24/7 pencils and I’m super impressed with the inglot cream liner I have ????

That sounds awesome Jen! I have yet to give it enough runs, but I’ll keep going at it now that you mention it!

Inglot gel liner is THE BEST!!! It is totally smudge-free on me and glides really smoothly over my kinda rough lids. Great picks!

Oh that’s lovely Julie! It can be so hard to find the it eyeliner sometimes!

I don’t think I’ve tried ANY of those liners! But just looking at your swatches, I think I’d like the Make Up Forever Ink liner. Have you tried the LORAC’s pen liner? That’s my favorite one, as of right now. It’s really easy to wing out your liner and it’s very black. ????

I actually haven’t tried that one yet – you’re making me want to now!

I’ll have to try the MUFE Ink Liner! My current favourite liner is the Kat Von D Ink Liner (the one with the felt tip).

I’ve heard only good things about that one – looking forward to what you think of the MUFE one too!

I haven’t tried any of them but it would be very useful for e to try them, I have a very bad luck with eyeliners and I need a good one

Definitely try one of these ????

While I love the Stila liner, I think Kat Von D’s really takes the top spot for me because I like the brush tip better. I’m also kinda sad that the Urban Decay pencils just don’t work for me! They’re super creamy, pigmentation is spot-on, but they just smudge all over the place for me (even with primer and powder). That Inglot gel liner looks sooo good though, so I’m interested in trying it out!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *